NUTRITION

The 5 Best Protein Cookies in 2024, Tested and Reviewed

By Emma ParkerUpdated on Nov 26, 2024

Protein cookies have become a popular snack among fitness enthusiasts, offering a convenient way to increase protein intake while satisfying sweet cravings. After thorough testing and evaluation, we've compiled a list of the best protein cookies available in 2024 to support your fitness goals.

Legion Chocolate Chip Protein Cookies

Legion Chocolate Chip Protein Cookies image

4.8

  • 15g protein and 9g prebiotic fiber per cookie
  • Naturally sweetened with stevia and monk fruit
  • No artificial substances or food dyes
  • Soft-baked with a classic chocolate chip flavor
  • Individually wrapped for on-the-go convenience

On Amazon

Why We Recommend It

Legion's Chocolate Chip Protein Cookies combine clean ingredients with a satisfying taste, making them a great choice for health-conscious individuals.

Pros & Cons

Clean ingredient list

High fiber content

Naturally sweetened

Premium pricing

Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie

Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie image

4.8

  • 16g plant-based protein per cookie
  • Vegan and non-GMO ingredients
  • No artificial sweeteners or sugar alcohols
  • Available in multiple flavors including Chocolate Chip and Snickerdoodle
  • Soft-baked texture for a satisfying bite

On Amazon

Why We Recommend It

Lenny & Larry's The Complete Cookie offers a substantial protein boost with plant-based ingredients, making it suitable for vegans and those seeking a natural snack option.

Pros & Cons

High protein content

Vegan-friendly

Wide variety of flavors

Higher sugar content compared to some competitors

My Cookie Dealer Protein Cookies

My Cookie Dealer Protein Cookies image

4.8

  • 18g protein per 4oz cookie
  • Made with RAW Nutrition Protein
  • Individually wrapped for convenience
  • Available in flavors like Milk and Cookies
  • Soft-baked with a rich flavor profile

On Amazon

Why We Recommend It

My Cookie Dealer Protein Cookies offer a decadent treat with a substantial protein content, ideal for satisfying sweet cravings post-workout.

Pros & Cons

High protein content

Rich and indulgent flavors

Convenient packaging

Higher calorie count per cookie

Quest Nutrition Protein Cookie

Quest Nutrition Protein Cookie image

4.6

  • 15g protein and 9g fiber per cookie
  • Less than 1g of sugar
  • Gluten-free and keto-friendly
  • Available in flavors like Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter
  • Soft and chewy texture

On Amazon

Why We Recommend It

Quest Nutrition Protein Cookies provide a high-protein, low-sugar option suitable for those following a keto or low-carb diet.

Pros & Cons

Low sugar content

High fiber

Gluten-free

Some flavors may have a slight aftertaste due to sweeteners

Jocko Fuel High Protein Snacks

Jocko Fuel High Protein Snacks image

4.5

  • 14g protein per cookie
  • No added sugar
  • Keto-friendly with no sugar alcohols
  • Available in Chocolate Chip flavor
  • Individually wrapped for convenience

On Amazon

Why We Recommend It

Jocko Fuel's High Protein Snacks provide a keto-friendly option with no added sugar, suitable for those adhering to strict dietary protocols.

Pros & Cons

No added sugar

Keto-friendly

Convenient packaging

Limited flavor options


When selecting a protein cookie, consider factors such as protein content, sugar levels, dietary restrictions, and flavor preferences to find the best fit for your nutritional needs and taste. The products listed above have been tested and reviewed to ensure they meet the standards for a satisfying and protein-rich snack.

What Are Protein Cookies, and How Are They Different from Regular Cookies?

Protein cookies are a healthier alternative to traditional cookies, designed to provide a higher protein content while still satisfying your sweet tooth. Unlike regular cookies, which are typically loaded with sugar and empty calories, protein cookies are formulated with ingredients like whey protein, plant-based protein, or egg whites to support muscle repair and growth.

Many protein cookies are lower in sugar and carbs, often including added fiber or healthy fats to create a balanced snack. They’re a great option for fitness enthusiasts, those seeking post-workout snacks, or anyone looking for a more nutritious treat.


Pro Tip: Check the nutrition label to find protein cookies that align with your dietary goals!

Are Protein Cookies a Healthy Snack?

Yes, protein cookies can be a healthy snack when chosen wisely! They offer a convenient way to boost your protein intake, which supports muscle repair, satiety, and overall health. Unlike regular cookies, protein cookies often have less sugar and more balanced nutrition, including added fiber and healthy fats.

However, not all protein cookies are created equal—some may contain artificial ingredients or excess calories. To ensure they’re a healthy option, check the nutrition label for high protein content, minimal sugar, and wholesome ingredients.


Pro Tip: Use protein cookies as a supplement to a balanced diet, not a meal replacement!

How Much Protein Should a Protein Cookie Have?

A good protein cookie should contain 10–20 grams of protein per serving, depending on your fitness goals and dietary needs. This amount is sufficient to support muscle recovery, satiety, and overall nutrition without overloading on calories.

If you’re using protein cookies as a post-workout snack, aim for cookies on the higher end of the protein spectrum. For casual snacking or adding a protein boost to your day, lower amounts can still be beneficial.


Pro Tip: Balance protein content with low sugar and wholesome ingredients for the healthiest option!

Are Protein Cookies Good for Weight Loss?

Protein cookies can support weight loss when consumed as part of a balanced diet. Their high protein content helps keep you fuller for longer, reducing cravings and preventing overeating. Many protein cookies are also lower in sugar and carbs compared to regular cookies, making them a healthier snack option.

However, be mindful of the calorie content and portion sizes. While they’re better than traditional cookies, some protein cookies can still be calorie-dense. Choose options with wholesome ingredients and minimal added sugar for the best results.


Pro Tip: Use protein cookies as a satisfying snack, not a meal replacement, to stay on track with your weight loss goals!

What Ingredients Should I Look for in a Healthy Protein Cookie?

When choosing a healthy protein cookie, focus on these key ingredients:

  1. High-Quality Protein: Look for sources like whey, casein, pea, or almond protein to support muscle repair and growth.
  2. Whole Grains or Natural Binders: Oats or almond flour are healthier options for added fiber and nutrients.
  3. Healthy Fats: Ingredients like nuts, seeds, or coconut oil provide sustained energy and satiety.
  4. Low Sugar: Opt for cookies with natural sweeteners like stevia, monk fruit, or minimal added sugars.
  5. Simple, Clean Ingredients: Avoid artificial additives or preservatives for a more wholesome snack.

Do Protein Cookies Taste Good Compared to Regular Cookies?

Protein cookies have come a long way and can taste delicious, but they’re different from regular cookies. While they’re designed to be healthier and packed with protein, their texture and sweetness may vary due to reduced sugar and added protein. Many brands now use natural sweeteners and premium ingredients to deliver flavors like chocolate chip, peanut butter, or oatmeal that satisfy cravings without the guilt.

Related Articles